McCoy Pottery Value & Identification
Estimated value · from sold prices
$15 – $1,000
Indicative educational range — not a formal appraisal.
Have this exact piece?
Upload a photo — get a value range for your item. 3 free / day · no signup.
McCoy is a beloved mid-century American pottery, best known for cookie jars and planters. Common planters and vases sell for about $15–$80, while collectible cookie jars — especially figural ones — run $50–$300, and the most sought-after figural jars reach into the hundreds. An original, matching lid is essential for cookie jars (a missing lid cuts value 50–80%). Two big cautions: counterfeit McCoy cookie jars (notably certain figural designs) flood the market, so compare mark crispness and weight; and Brush-McCoy is a different company. Verify the impressed McCoy mark, confirm the lid, and check condition (chips are severe) before valuing.
What drives the value
Form
Cookie jars — especially figural — beat common planters and vases.
Original lid & condition
A matching original lid is essential; chips cut value hard.
Authenticity
Counterfeit figural jars are common — verify mark crispness and weight.
Typical sold price ranges
Counterfeit McCoy cookie jars are widespread — verify the mark and weight; a missing lid or a reproduction drastically changes value.
Care & conservation
Confirm the McCoy mark (not Brush-McCoy); keep the original lid; check for chips.
Frequently asked
Are McCoy cookie jars faked?
Yes — some figural McCoy cookie jars are widely counterfeited. Compare mark crispness, weight and glaze to a known original before paying a premium.
Does a missing lid matter?
A lot — a cookie jar missing its original lid typically loses 50–80% of its value. The matching lid is essential.